Click on the headline to link to updates from the Occupy Boston website. Occupy Boston started at 6:00 PM, September 30, 2011. I will post important updates as they appear on that site.
****
An Injury To One Is An Injury To All!-Defend All The Occupation Sites And All The Occupiers! Drop All Charges Against All Protesters Everywhere!
********
Fight-Don’t Starve-We Created The Wealth, Let's Take It, It’s Ours! Labor And The Oppressed Must Rule!
********
Below I am posting, occasionally, comments on the
Occupy movement as I see or hear things of interest, or that cause alarm bells to ring in my head. The first comment directly below from October 1, which represented my first impressions of
Occupy Boston, is the lead for all further postings.
*******
Markin comment October 1, 2011:
There is a lot of naiveté expressed about the nature of capitalism, capitalists, and the way to win in the class struggle by various participants in this occupation. Many also have attempted to make a virtue out of that naiveté, particularly around the issues of effective democratic organization (the General Assembly, its unrepresentative nature and its undemocratic consensus process) and relationships with the police (they are not our friends, no way, when the deal goes down). However, their spirit is refreshing, they are acting out of good subjective anti-capitalist motives and, most importantly, even those of us who call ourselves "reds" (communists), including this writer, started out from liberal premises as naive, if not more so, than those encountered at the occupation site. We can all learn something but in the meantime we must defend the "occupation" and the occupiers. More later as the occupation continues.
**********
As part of my comment here, dated October 20, 2011, I noted the following:
“… The idea of the General Assembly with each individual attendee acting as a “tribune of the people” is interesting and important. And, of course, it represents, for today anyway, the embryo of what the “new world” we need to create might look like at the governmental level.”
A couple of the people that I have talked to were not quite sure what to make of that idea. The idea that what is going on in
Occupy Boston at the governmental level could, should, would be a possible form of governing this society in the “new world a-borning” with the rise of the
Occupy movement. Part of the problem is that there was some confusion on the part of the listeners that one of the possible aims of this movement is to create an alternative government, or at least provide a model for such a government. I will argue here now, and in the future, that it should be one the goals. In short, we need to take power away from the Democrats and Republicans and their tired old congressional/executive/judicial doesn’t work checks and balances form of governing and place it at the grassroots level and work upward from there rather than, as now, have power devolve from the top. (And stop well short of the bottom.)
I will leave aside the question (the problem really) of what it would take to create such a possibility. Of course a revolutionary solution would, of necessity, have be on the table since there is no way that the current powerful interests, Democratic, Republican or those having no named politics, is going to give up power without a fight. What I want to pose now is the use of the General Assembly as a deliberative executive, legislative, and judicial body all rolled into one. In that sense previous historical models come to mind; the short-lived but heroic Paris Commune of 1871 that Karl Marx tirelessly defended against the reactionaries of Europe as the prototype of a workers government; the early heroic days of the Russian October Revolution of 1917 when the workers councils (soviets in Russian parlance) acted as a true workers' government; and the period in the Spanish Revolution of 1936-39 where the Central Committee of the Anti-Fascist Militias acted,
de facto, as a workers government. All the just mentioned examples had their problems and flaws, no question. However, merely mentioning the General Assembly concept in the same paragraph as these great historic examples should signal that thoughtful leftists and other militants need to investigate and study these examples.
**********
Recently (see October 22, 2011 comment above) I noted the following while arguing for the General Assembly concept as a form of alternate government using historic examples like the Paris Commune (1871), the early soviets in Russia (1905 and 1917), and the early days of the antifascist militias in the Spanish Civil War (1936-37):
“However, merely mentioning the General Assembly concept in the same paragraph as these great historic examples should signal that thoughtful leftists and other militants need to investigate and study these examples.”
In order to facilitate the investigation and study of those examples I will, occasionally, post works in this space that deal with these forbears from several leftist perspectives (rightist perspectives were clear- crush all the above examples ruthlessly, and with no mercy- so we need not look at them now). I started this Lesson Of History series with Karl Marx’s classic defense and critique of the Paris Commune,
The Civil War In France and today’s presentation noted in the headline continues on in that same vein.
********
Markin comment January 15, 2012
In several recent comments in this space (in late December) my old radical friend and alternative newspaper commentator, Josh Breslin, noted that the Occupy movement seemed to have lost energy and was , as he vividly described it, a movement of generals without an army. I, initially, argued with him about that characterization saying that this was just a period of growing pains and things would sort themselves out over the next several months. Then a series of disturbing events occurred topped off by what I will here call the “sex registry question” to make me thing that old Josh, once again, was right. Only I would characterize things, unlike Josh, as a succumbing to the circle spirit and as yet another example of the revolution devouring its own. In either case not a healthy situation.
With that said, I have long noted that although I believed that the General Assembly concept was potentially the embryo of an alternate form of government that would drive our vision for a new society there were some structural problems with the concept as practiced. Among those criticisms were the simple notions that majority rule and representative government based on political positions were concepts better suited to the struggle. Well, apparently others have, in the crucible of struggle, learned some of those lessons. Lessons that, perhaps, needed to be painfully worked through in practice before their shortcomings could be exposed. In any case this latest news from OB (consenting to a once a week strategic assembly) about a willingness to think about other governing forms is welcome news. Whether we remain generals without an army can now be hashed out but one thing seems certain this will go a long way toward breaking out of the circle spirit.
*******
A Five-Point Program As Talking Points
*
Jobs For All Now!-“30 For 40”- A historic demand of the labor movement. Thirty hours work for forty hours pay to spread the available work around. Organize the unorganized- Organize the South- Organize Wal-Mart- Defend the right for public and private workers to unionize.
*
Defend the working classes! No union dues for Democratic (or the stray Republican) candidates. Spent the dough on organizing the unorganized and other labor-specific causes (example, the November, 2011 anti-union recall referendum in Ohio).
*
End the endless wars!- Immediate, Unconditional Withdrawal Of All U.S./Allied Troops (And Mercenaries) From Afghanistan! Hands Off Pakistan! Hands Off Iran! Hands Off The World!
*
Fight for a social agenda for working people!. Quality Healthcare For All! Nationalize the colleges and universities under student-teacher-campus worker control! Forgive student debt! Stop housing foreclosures!
*
We created the wealth, let’s take it back. Take the struggle for our daily bread off the historic agenda. Build a workers party that fights for a workers government to unite all the oppressed.
Emblazon on our red banner-Labor and the oppressed must rule!
********
Gracchus Babeuf and the Conspiracy of the Equals 1796
Fragment of a Projected Economic Decree
Source; Ph. Buonarroti. La conspiration pour l'égalité, Editions Sociales, Paris. 1957;
Translated: for marxists.org by Mitchell Abidor;
CopyLeft: Creative Commons (Attribute & ShareAlike) marxists.org 2004.
In 1828, more than thirty years after the Conspiracy’s failure, Philippe (born in Pisa as Filippo, and a descendant of Michelangelo) Buonarroti, one of its leaders (and its greatest chronicler), set down on paper the new economic order the Equals sought to establish. It’s a vision that looks something like a Fourierist phalanstery, a kolkhoz, a kibbutz, and war communism, all growing from the left-wing of Jacobinism.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Art. 1
In the Republic there will be established a great national community
Art. 2
The national community consists of the following goods, to wit:
Goods which, having been declared national, were not sold the 9th Thermidor of the year II;
Goods of enemies of the Revolution, which the decrees of the 8th to the 13th Ventose of the year II had given the poor;
Goods having fallen due to the Republic as a result of judicial condemnation;
Buildings currently occupied by the public service;
Goods which communes enjoyed use of before the law of June 10, 1793;
Goods turned over to alms-houses and establishments of public instruction;
Lodgings occupied by poor citizens in the carrying out of the proclamation to the French of ...;
Goods of those who have abandoned the Republic;
Goods usurped by those who enriched themselves in the exercise of public functions;
Goods whose owners neglect their cultivation.
Art. 3
The right of succession ab intestate or by testament is abolished; all goods currently owned by individuals will revert, upon their death, to the national community.
Art. 4
Shall be considered “current owner” those children of a father today living who are not called by law to the army.
Art. 5
Every Frenchman, of one or the other sex, who abandons all his goods to the fatherland, and who consecrates to it his person and the work of which he is capable, is a member of the great national community.
Art. 6
The elderly, who have reached their 60th year, and the infirm, if they are poor, are by right members of the national community.
Art. 7
Are also members of the national community young people raised in national houses of education.
Art. 8
The goods of the national community are exploited in common by all able-bodied members
Art. 9
The great national community maintains all its members in an equal and honest mediocrity; it furnishes them with all they need.
Art. 10
The Republic invites good citizens to contribute to the success of this reform by a voluntary abandonment of their goods to the community.
Art. 11
Effective ..., no one can be a civil or military functionary if he is not a member of said community.
Art. 12
The great national community is administered by local magistrates chosen by its members, under the laws and under the direction of the Supreme Administration.
Art. 13
...
ON COMMON LABOR
Art. 1
Every member of the national community owes it the agricultural labor and the useful arts of which he is capable.
Art. 2
The elderly aged 60 years and the infirm are excepted.
Art. 3
Those citizens who by the voluntary abandonment of their goods become members of the national community, will not be forced to submit to any painful labor, if they’ve reached their 40th year, and if they didn’t exercise a mechanical trade before the publication of the present decree.
Art. 4
In each commune the citizens are distributed by class; there are as many classes as useful arts; each class is composed of those who work in the same art.
Art. 5
In each class there are magistrates named by those who compose it. These magistrates direct the labor, ensure equal distribution, carry out the orders of the municipal administration, and set an example of zeal and activity.
Art. 6
For each season, the law determines the duration of the workday for members of the national community
Art. 7
Each municipal administration has a council of elders, delegated by each class of laborers; this council enlightens the administration on all that concerns the distribution, the lightening, and the improvement of work.
Art. 8
The supreme administration shall apply to the labors of the national community the use of machines and those processes needed to diminish the suffering of men.
Art. 9
The municipal administration constantly has before its eyes the state of the laborers of each class, and that of the tasks they must accomplish: it will regularly instruct the Supreme Administration of this.
Art. 10
The movement of laborers from one commune to another is ordered by the Supreme Administration, according to its knowledge of the strengths and needs of the community.
Art. 11
The Supreme Administration obliges to work at forced labor those individuals of the two sexes whose lack of civic spirit, idleness, profligacy, and disorders set society a pernicious example. Their goods are turned over to the national community.
Art. 12
The magistrates of each class watch over the stock in the storehouses of the national community, the fruits of the earth, and the products of the arts capable of conservation.
Art. 13
The accounting of these objects is regularly communicated to the Supreme Administration
Art. 14
The magistrates attached to the agricultural class have guard over the propagation and improvement of animals that can be used as food, clothing, transport, and for the lightening of human labor.
ON THE DISTRIBUTION AND USE OF COMMON GOODS
Art. 1
Members of the national community can only enjoy the use of that the which law gives him according to the magistrate’s distribution of property.
Art. 2
From this time forward, the national community assures each of its members:
A healthy, comfortable, and properly furnished lodging; work and leisure clothes of linen or wool, in conformity with the national costume; laundry, lighting and heat; a sufficient quantity of foodstuffs in the form of bread, meat, fowl, fish, eggs, butter or oil, wine and other drinks commonly used in the various regions; vegetables, fruits, seasoning, and other objects with the gathering together of constitutes a mediocre and frugal ease; the assistance of the healing arts.
Art. 3
In each commune there will be, at pre-determined times, meals in common, which all members must attend.
Art. 4
The pay rate of public functionaries and the military will be the same as that of the members of the national community.
Art. 5
Any member of the national community who receives a salary, or keeps money, is punished.
Art. 6
Members of the national community can only receive the common ration in the district in which they reside, except for transfers authorized by the administration.
Art .7
The domicile of those who are currently citizens is that which they enjoy at the time of publication of the present decree. That of young people raised in houses of national education is their commune of birth.
Art. 8
In each community there are magistrates charged with the distribution to the homes of members of the national community of the products of agriculture and the arts.
Art. 9
The law determines the rules of this distribution
Art. 10
...
ON THE ADMINISTRATION OF THE NATIONAL COMMUNITY
Art. 1
The national community is under the legal direction of the Supreme Administration of the state.
Art. 2
As regards administration, the Republic is divided into regions.
Art. 3
A region consists of all contiguous departments of which the products are more or less the same.
Art. 4
In each region there is an Intermediate Administration to which Departmental Administrations are subordinated.
Art. 5
Telegraph lines speed up the correspondence between departmental and intermediate administrations, and between these and the Supreme Administration.
Art. 6
In accordance with the law, the Supreme Administration determines the nature and amount to be distributed to members of the community in each region.
Art. 7
In accordance with this determination, the Departmental Administration makes known to the Intermediate Administration the deficit or surplus of the respective districts.
Art. 8
As far as possible, the Intermediate Administrations fill the deficit of one department by the surplus of another, order deposits and necessary transport, and give an accounting to the Supreme Administration of their needs or their surplus.
Art. 9
The Supreme Administration meets the needs of regions that are lacking in certain objects with the overflow of those with too much, or by foreign trade.
Art. 10
Above all, every year the Supreme Administration deducts and deposits in military stores a tenth of all the community harvests.
Art. 11
It ensures that the surplus of the Republic is carefully saved for famine years.
ON COMMERCE
Art. 1
All individual commerce with foreign peoples is forbidden. Any merchandise from this source will be confiscated to the profit of the national community. Violators will be punished.
Art. 2
The Republic procures for the national community the objects it lacks by exchanging its surplus in agriculture and manufactured goods for those of foreign peoples.
Art 3
To this effect, appropriate warehouses are established on the land and sea borders.
Art. 4
The Supreme Administration trades with foreigners by means of its agents; it deposits the surplus that it wishes to exchange in the warehouses, where it receives from foreigners the agreed-upon goods.
Art. 5
The agents of the Supreme Administration in the commercial warehouses are often changed. The dishonest are severely punished.
ON TRANSPORT
Art. 1
In each commune there are magistrates charged with the directing of communal goods from one commune to another.
Art. 2
Each commune is granted sufficient means of transport, by land and by sea.
Art. 3
The members of the national community are in turn called upon to drive and keep guard over the objects transported from one commune to another.
Art. 4
Every year the Intermediate Administrations commission a certain number of young people, taken from all the departments subordinate to them, to carry out the most distant transports.
Art. 5
Citizens commissioned to handle any transport, are maintained in the communes in which they are found.
Art. 6
The Supreme Administration transports from commune to commune those objects by which they fill the deficits of regions in need by the shortest route, under the guard of the Lower Administration.
ON CONTRIBUTIONS
Art. 1
Those individuals who do not participate in the national community are the sole taxpayers.
Art. 2
They owe the contributions established in the preceding.
Art. 3
These contributions will be made in kind, and deposited in the storehouses of the national community.
Art. 4
The sum due from this year’s taxpayers is double that of last year.
Art. 5
This total will be broken down by department, and levied against taxpayers in a progressive fashion.
Art. 6
Non-participants in the community can be required, in case of need, to deposit in the storehouse of the national community an advance on future contributions, in the form of their surplus of agricultural or manufactured goods.
ON DEBTS
Art. 1
The national debt is erased for all Frenchmen
Art 2
The Republic will reimburse foreigners for the capital amount of the perpetual pensions it owes them. It sets the rates for this, as well as that of lifetime annuities, on a per capita basis.
Art. 3
The debts owed to another Frenchman by any Frenchman who becomes a member of the national community are erased.
Art. 4
The Republic assumes responsibility for the debts owed by members of the community to foreigners
Art. 5
Any fraud in this matter is punished by perpetual slavery.
ON MONIES
Art. 1
The Republic no longer issues money.
Art 2
Minted matter which falls due to the national community will be employed in purchasing from foreign peoples those objects it needs.
Art. 3
Any individual not participating in the community who shall be convicted of having offered minted matter to one of its members will be severely punished.
Art. 4
Neither gold nor silver will ever again be brought into the Republic.
