I
Did It My Way-With Bob Dylan’s Frank Sinatra “Shadows In The Night” In Mind
By
Sam Lowell
If
anybody has read the introduction to my review of an early part of these
American Songbook series about the legendary Jim Kweskin and the Jug Band dated
January 11, 2018 In The Beginning Was The
Jug…in the archives you will already know that I have been given the task
of writing the history of this site and it personnel as well as the internal
in-fighting that roiled the publication over the last few months of 2017 in
order to finally put an end to the turmoil. Below is one part of that history
which I have decided I need to cut into parts or the whole project will
overwhelm me. If you want to skip this and wait until the whole project is
archived be my guest. I will let you know when the whole thing is complete.
***********
The
American Left History blog has been
in cyberspace, on-line, for the past fifteen years or so and which readers can
reference to any particular article via the ALF
archives. What many people do not know is that there has been a much longer
history to the ideas and purpose of the site going back to the 1970s and maybe
even a little to the 1960s if you add in Peter Paul Markin’s work, the real
Peter Paul Markin who I will talk about later when I explain why I used the
word “real” before his name. In those days, the Summer of Love, 1967 days the
50th anniversary last year of which started the firestorm that
followed over the latter part of 2017 at this publication Markin worked on and
off for The Eye and The East Bay Other two of what were
called in those days alternative newspaper to distinguish them from the main
stream media which gave short shrift to the political and cultural events that
stirred us, you know the New York Times
and Washington Post. Sound familiar? Except those alternative
publications did not deal with so-called alternative facts or carry on about
conspiracy theories like today but other things of interest to young people,
“hippies” for lack of a better word that the mainstream media were clueless
about.
That
Peter Paul Markin that I mentioned above won a few awards for his articles, his
series on his fellow Vietnam War veterans some who like him had a hard time
adjusting to what they called the “real” world, the non-Vietnam world and set
up camps and such along the rivers and railroad tracks out in Southern
California where he joined them for a time because he himself had a hard time
adjusting as well and told their stories. No, that is wrong, let them tell
their stories. The series entitled The Embattled
Brothers Of Westminster (one of the biggest railroad campsites) would from
what I heard inspired Lenny Lawrence to write a very popular song about those
lost souls using that title if I recall. So that was one early piece of what
would follow over the next forty years or so.
Markin,
everybody called him Scribe when he was growing up and that name stuck but I
will use Markin here was not alone in working for those publications. After he
got back from Vietnam he reunited with Josh Breslin, yes, Josh Breslin who
writes for this blog even now so you can start to make the long drawn out connections,
a guy from up in Olde Saco, Maine whom he met out in San Francisco during the
Summer of Love, 1967 (you can also start to see how that event, how those times
played a key role as well in what followed) and Allan Jackson whom he, we, had
grown up with in North Adamsville and had followed Markin, as I did as well, out
to the Summer of Love. The three of them were all crazy to write, write about
the war, write about the counter-culture everything and The Eye and later The East
Bay Other were ready-made for guys who wanted to look at the steamy, seamy
side of life.
Like
most things in the 1960s when the hammer went down, when the war turned
everybody sour, and then later in reaction the other side decided that things
had gone too far and started a counter-offensive which more than one writer,
young or old, in this space has noted has been going on for the past forty
years or so things like grassroots, fly-by-the-seat-of –your-pants and woefully
underfunded alternative newspapers were going to ground in droves. That was the
fate of those two papers. Josh, Markin, Allan and I would join them as well in
the mid-1970s after I had been roaming around the country “sowing my oats” as
my grandfather used to say although he would have been mortified at my motto,
our generational motto-“drugs, sex, and rock and roll” were crazy to continue
writing, writing the kind of stuff they had been writing but with a little more
of a political twist than those mainly culturally-oriented papers had been.
That is where the idea for Progressive
Nation came from in the beginning. The Progressive
Nation that a number of us still write for on occasion although it had changed
from our hands and from our brand of left-wing street politics many years
ago.
That
idea though almost went stillborn for a while for one main reason-that real
Peter Paul Markin who I have been alluding to. We had gathered some seed money
from a few still extant “hippies” with trust funds to get the publication
started mainly through Markin and Josh’s connections via The Eye and The East Bay Other.
The rest of the financing would come from advertisers (we were totally
naïve about the horrible influence that would have on what we were trying to do
with our good idea. If you want a current day example of just how off the rails
a good idea can go once the advertisers sink their claws in check out an early
version of Rolling Stone and one
today-Egad) and other “angels” and subscribers. Then Markin ran away with the
money to buy dope, to buy the emerging cocaine that he would eventually become
addicted to and which would cost him his life down in Sonora, Mexico over a
busted drug deal when he was the loser, the six feet under in a potter’s field
grave which still has unexplained parts to the story until this day.
That
obviously is the bad part about Markin, that “from hunger” part that he more
than the rest of us never got over. And which Vietnam only accentuated. Not
that the war did him in like many others but it did not help either the few
times he would talk about his experiences, about what he had had to do, and had
seen others do as well in that hell-hole. But the good part, the part that
wanted the revolution to win, the world to be turned upside down is the part we
knew and loved. Not all the guys we grew up with had those same feelings, the
guys who had no dough like us and hung around street corners to get out of
tumultuous home life, but a small crew did, a crew that was always led by
Markin. Not a leader in the organizational sense that was Frankie Riley who has
written a few things here about Markin, but in the spiritual sense is the best
way I can put it.
That
is what has bound Allan Jackson, Si Lannon, Jack Callahan, Bart Webber, Frank and
me over the long years. That buying into Markin’s vision even though he
personally could not go the distance, came up short. Funny before we lost track
of him, or really Josh Breslin lost track of him since he was his housemate in
Oakland in the days when they had a communal house there and he was the last
person to see Markin alive in America Markin would always say that Progressive Nation would carry us into
our old ages. That did not happen since I have already mentioned he flew the coop
and later when we got some more dough and published for a while we sold that
enterprise off when the political winds shifted dramatically in the 1980s and
we had to cut our loses. What did happen and made Markin a prophet after all
was that we then established the hard copy version of ALH and then went on-line I think in 2003. All from that original
ideal spawned by the real Markin. So it was a no-brainer when we started the
on-line version that Allan Jackson our site manager when it came time to take
cyberspace necessary monikers would go back to the old days, to our growing up
days and honor our fallen brother by using his moniker in this space. Hell, it
just seemed right.
More
next time
******
A
couple of years ago when I was Senior Film Critic before I gained emeritus
status and before Greg Green the new site manager abolished all titles which
the previous site manager had bestowed on senior personnel, many his longtime
friends and co-workers I did a review of Bob Dylan’s latest CD, Shadows In
The Night, a tribute to the king of Tin Pan Alley Frank Sinatra. In that
review I noted that such an effort was bound to happen if Dylan lived long
enough. Strange as it may seem to a generation, the generation of ’68, the AARP
generation, okay, baby-boomers who came of age with the clarion call put forth
musically by Bob Dylan and others to dramatically break with the music of our
parents’ pasts, the music that got them through the Great Depression and slogging
through World War II, he has put out an album featuring the work of Mr. Frank
Sinatra the king of that era in many our parents’ households. The music of the
Broadway shows, Tin Pan Alley, Cole Porter/Irving Berlin/ the Gershwins and so
on. That proposition though seems less strange if you are not totally mired in
the Bob Dylan protest minute of the early 1960s when he, whether he wanted that
designation or not, was the “voice of a generation,” catching the new breeze a
lot of us felt coming through the land.
What
Dylan has been about for the greater part of his career has been as an
entertainer, a guy who sings his songs to the crowd and hopes they share his
feelings for his songs however he is interpreting them at the time. Just like
Frank when he was in high tide. What Dylan has also been about through it all
has been a deep and abiding respect for the American songbook (look on YouTube
to a clip from Don’t Look Back where
he is singing Hank Williams stuff or a ton of country stuff from
the Basement tapes). In the old days that was looking for roots, roots
music from the mountains, the desolate oceans, the slave quarters, along the
rivers and Dylan’s hero then was Woody Guthrie. But the American songbook is a
“big tent” operation and the Tin Pan Alley that he broke from when he became
his own songwriter is an important part of the overall tradition and now his
hero is Frank Sinatra.
I
may long for the old protest songs, the songs from the album pictured above,
you know Blowin’ In The Wind, The Times Are A Changin’ stuff like that,
the roots music and not just Woody but Hank, Tex-Mex, the Carters, the odd and
unusual like Desolation Row or his cover of Lonnie Johnson’s Tomorrow
Night but Dylan has sought to entertain and there is room in his tent for
the king of Tin Pan Alley (as Billie Holiday was the queen). Having heard Dylan
live and in concert over the past several years with his grating lost voice (it
was always about the lyrics not the voice even when young but now that voice seems
not to bad) I do wonder though how much production was needed to get the
wrinkles out of that voice to sing as smoothly as the “Chairman of the boards.”
What goes around comes around.
The Answer My Friend Is Blowing (No Clipped “G”) In The Wind-The Influence Of Bob Dylan’s “The Times
They Are A-Changin’” On The “Generation of’68”-The Best Part Of That Cohort
Link to NPR Morning Edition 'The Times They Are A-Changin" Still Speaks To Our Changing Times https://www.npr.org/2018/09/24/650548856/american-anthem-the-times-they-are-a-changin
By Seth Garth
No question this
publication both in its former hard copy editions and now more so in the
on-line editions as the, ouch, 50th anniversary of many signature
events for the “Generation of ‘68” have come and gone that the whole period of
the 1950s and 1960s had gotten a full airing. Has been dissected, deflected,
inspected, reflected and even rejected beyond compare. That is not to say that
this trend won’t continue if for no other reason that the demographics and
actual readership response indicate that people still have a desire to not
forget their pasts, their youth.
(Under the new site manager
Greg Green, despite what I consider all good sense having worked under taskmaster
Allan Jackson, we are encouraged to give this blessed readership some inside
dope, no, no that kind, about how things are run these days in an on-line
publication. With that okay in mind there was a huge controversy that put the
last sentence in the above paragraph in some perspective recently when Greg for
whatever ill-begotten reason thought that he would try to draw in younger
audiences by catering to their predilections-for comic book character movies,
video games, graphic novels and trendy music and got nothing but serious
blow-back from those who have supported this publication financially and
otherwise both in hard copy times and now on-line. What that means as the target
demographic fades is another question and maybe one for a future generation who
might take over the operation. Or perhaps like many operations this one will
not outlast its creators- and their purposes.)
Today’s 1960s question, a
question that I have asked over the years and so I drew the assignment to
address the issue-who was the voice of the 1960s. Who or what. Was it the
lunchroom sit-inners and Freedom Riders, what it the hippies, was it SDS, the
various Weather configurations, acid, rock, folk rock, folk, Tom Hayden, Jane
Fonda, Abbie Hoffman, Grace Slick, hell the Three Js-Joplin, Jimi, Jim as in Morrison
and the like. Or maybe it was a mood, a mood of disenchantment about a world
that seemed out of our control, which seemed to be running without any input
from us, without us even being asked. My candidate, and not my only candidate
but a recent NPR Morning Edition
segment brought the question to mind (see above link), is a song, a song
created by Bob Dylan in the early 1960s which was really a clarion call to
action on our part, or the best part of our generation-The Times They Are A-Changin’.
I am not sure if Bob Dylan
started out with some oversized desire to be the “voice” of his generation. He
certainly blew the whole thing off later after his motorcycle accident and
still later when he became a recluse even if he did 200 shows a year, maybe
sullen introvert is better, actually maybe his own press agent giving out
dribbles is even better but that song, that “anthem” sticks in memory as a
decisive summing up of what I was feeling at the time. (And apparently has
found resonance with a new generation of activists via the March for Our Lives
movement and other youth-driven movements.) As a kid I was antsy to do
something, especially once I saw graphic footage on commercial television of
young black kids being water-hosed, beaten and bitten by dogs down in the South
simply for looking for some rough justice in this wicked old world. Those
images, and those of the brave lunch-room sitters and Freedom bus riders were
stark and compelling. They and my disquiet over nuclear bombs which were a lot
scarier then when there were serious confrontations which put them in play and
concern that what bothered me about having no say, about things not being
addressed galvanized me.
The song “spoke to me” as
it might not have earlier or later. It had the hopeful ring of a promise of a
newer world. That didn’t happen or happen in ways that would have helped the
mass of humanity but for that moment I flipped out every time I heard it played
on the radio or on my old vinyl records record-player. Other songs, events,
moods, later would overtake this song’s sentiment but I was there at the
creation. Remember that, please.