This space is dedicated to the proposition that we need to know the history of the struggles on the left and of earlier progressive movements here and world-wide. If we can learn from the mistakes made in the past (as well as what went right) we can move forward in the future to create a more just and equitable society. We will be reviewing books, CDs, and movies we believe everyone needs to read, hear and look at as well as making commentary from time to time. Greg Green, site manager
When The Winds Of War Do
Get Stirred Up- Sir Alfred Hitchcock’s “Foreign Correspondent” (1940)-A Film Review
DVD Review
By Sandy Salmon
Foreign Correspondent,
starry Lorraine Day, Joel McCrea, Herbert Marshall, directed by Sir Alfred
Hitchcock, 1940
Seth Garth and Alden
Riley have already gone over in some detail the Sir Alfred Hitchcock problem,
no, the problem of heavyweight male movers and shakers in all walks of upscale
life, here cinema, and their sexually predatory and in some cases criminal
practices toward the women, the professional women, they work with. The problem
of placing in some cinematic perspective the relationship between the cultural
importance of their work and their gutter-worthy personal lives as they affect
other members of the human race. What I want to address is a different Sir
Alfred Hitchcock problem, the problem of using his films in the immediate
pre-World War II period and beyond, a problem that also affected the extreme
bachelor coupling of Sir Sherlock Holmes and Sir John Watson in the same
period, of mixing cinematic values with low-rent propaganda for the Allied, no,
the British side in that epic war. The film under review could stand alone as a
good piece of cinema but is marred toward the end with some “speeches” that
could have been written by Sir Winston Churchill’s speech writers in Britannia’s
darkest hours.
That is all I have to
say about that aspect of the film, Foreign
Correspondent, except that looking backward on the plotline the whole thing
reeked more than a little as a rebuff to the American Firsters like Charles
Lindberg and Homer Martin in order to get America on board the European fiasco.
The start is pretty straight forward in a time when commercial newspapers were
a major source of news about the greater world and not fighting the culture
wars over “fake news,” social media and Everyman’s opinion disguised as
reportage. The editor and owner of the New
York World
wanted to know more
about the impeding war clouds in Europe than the hand-outs from the various
embassies which his current crew of so-called correspondents were spewing forth
between cocktails at five. Enter Johnny Reporter, it could be any name, played
by winsome Joel McCrea, hungry, raw and ignorant of any of the play in Europe
except he had a nose for grabbing some serious news and riding it out like with
a storm.
Assignment one, which
our boy Johnny never got past since this turned out to be his Pulitzer moment,
find out what some old- time peacenik diplomat thinks is going to happen and
what the terms of a peace alliance were all about. No problem as he runs into
the guy he needed to see minute one. Except that meeting started a whole series
of turns and twists which will lead him on a merry, merry goose chase. See the
dippy diplomat got himself “killed” while attending, or going to a attend a
world peace conference sponsored by a British national who is running a peace
party operation, or so the general naïve public think since there is plenty
going on which looks very suspicious after Johnny and another holy goof
reporter working his own angel angles and a naïve if attractive daughter of
said peace operative trace things to a windmill in the boondocks of Holland, in
the outback of the country where the whole fight for peace is taking place.
That dippy diplomat was
not killed but had been taken hostage to get a phrase from the secret peace
agreement which might just have averted the war. (Ho hum, we have been down
that road before when nations are hell-bent on war.) Taken hostage by forces unknown
except they all seen to speak German when given a chance and so the chase in
on. The twists and turns going running round like some second generation
running kind until it becomes inescapable that the peace operative (with that
naive but attractive daughter) is pulling all the strings-is an agent of the
unnamed fascists like a good many other well-bred and snobbish English gentry
who saw Hitler and Mussolini as the saviors against those troublesome workers
who were always asking for something or other. Kept order and trains on time
not necessarily in that order.
Here’s the beauty of the
whole charade, and the political baloney part as well. Once exposed as a
treacherous agent of the night-takers swarming over Europe like vultures our
good English gentleman with the nice manners flees London and with naïve if
attractive daughter in tow heads to, where else, neutral America, once war is
declared on a great looking airplane which seemed like the lap of luxury. Also
on board are the dogged Johnny R, and his buddy intrepid reporter. Out in
neutral waters the airplane is fired upon by a German destroyer and goes down
in the briny drink, the Atlantic. Among the survivors Johnny, Intrepid,
Attractive Daughter and Traitor Blue Dad. As a gesture of his suddenly found
“patriotism” Traitor Blue Dad slips himself into that briny deep, the Atlantic
when the wing of the plane they were floating on couldn’t handle the weight. So
that gesture, fake unlike all the stuff he did for the Nazis and their ilk,
gets him a pass on the traitor list. Baloney, double baloney.
When The Blues Was Dues-Howling At
The Moon-When Howlin’ Wolf Held Forth
From
The Pen Of Bart Webber
One night when Sam Eaton and Ralph
Morris were sitting in the now long gone Johnny D’s over in Somerville, over near the
Davis Square monster Redline MBTA stop sipping a couple of Anchor Steam beers,
a taste acquired by Sam out in Frisco town in the old days on hot nights like
that one waiting for the show to begin Ralph mentioned that some music you
acquired naturally, you know like kids’ songs learned in school. (The Farmer
in the Dell, which forced you a city kid although you might not have
designated yourself as such at that age to learn a little about the dying
profession of family farmer and about farm machinery, Old MacDonald, ditto
on the family farmer stuff and as a bonus the animals of the farm kingdom, Humpty
Dumpty, a silly overweight goof who couldn’t maintain his balance come hell
or high water although you might not have thought of that expression or used it
in the high Roman Catholic Morris household out in Troy, New York where Ralph
grew up and still lives, Jack and Jill and their ill-fated hill
adventure looking for water like they couldn’t have gone to the family kitchen
sink tap for their needs showing indeed whether you designated yourself as a
city kid or not you were one of the brethren, etc. in case you have forgotten.)
Music embedded in the back of your
mind, coming forth sometimes out of the blue even fifty years later (and maybe
relating to other memory difficulties among the AARP-worthy but we shall skip
over that since this is about the blues, the musical blues and not the day to
day getting old blues).
Or as in the case of music in junior
high school as Sam chimed in with his opinion as he thought about switching
over to a high-shelf whiskey, his natural drink of late, despite the hot night
and hot room beginning to fill up with blues aficionados who have come to
listen to the “second coming,” the blues of James Montgomery and his back-up
blues band. That “second coming” referring to guys like Montgomery and Eric
Clapton, now greying guys, who picked up the blues, especially the citified electric
blues after discovering the likes of Muddy Waters, Howlin’ Wolf, Magic Slim and
James Cotton back in their 1960s youth, made a decent living out of it and were
still playing small clubs and other venues to keep the tradition alive and to
pass it on to the kids who were not even born when the first wave guys came out
of the hell-hole Delta south of Mister James Crow sometime around or after
World War II and plugged their guitars into the next gin mill electric
outlet in places off of Maxwell Street in Chicago, nursing their acts, honing
their skills.
Yeah, that hormonal bust out junior
high weekly music class with Mr. Dasher which made Sam chuckle a bit, maybe
that third bottle of beer sipping getting him tipsy a little, as he thought
about the old refrain, “Don’t be a masher, Mister Dasher” which all the kids
hung on him that time when the rhyming simon craze was going through the
nation’s schools. Thinking just then that today if some teacher or school
administrator was astute enough to bother to listen to what teenage kids say
amongst themselves, an admittedly hard task for an adult, in an excess of
caution old Mister Dasher might be in a peck of trouble if anyone wanted to be
nasty about the implication of that innocent rhyme. Yeah, Mr. Dasher, the
mad monk music teacher, who wanted his charges to have a well-versed knowledge
of the American and world songbooks so you were forced to remember such songs
as The Mexican Hat Dance and Home On The Range under penalty of
being sent up to the front of the room songbook in hand and sing the damn
things. Yes, you will remember such songs unto death. (Sam and his corner boys
at Doc’s Drugstore found out later that Dasher was motivated by a desperate rear-guard action
to wean his charges away from rock and roll, away from the devil’s music
although he would not have called it that because he was too cool to say stuff
like that, a struggle in which he was both woefully overmatched by Elvis, Jerry
Lee, Chuck, Bo, and the crowd and wasting his breathe as they all lived for
rock and roll at Doc’s Drugstore after school where he had a jukebox at his
soda fountain.)
Ralph agreed running through his own
junior high school litany with Miss Hunt (although a few years older than Sam
he had not run through the rhyming simon craze so had no moniker for the old
witch although now he wished he had and it would not be nice either). He added
that some of the remembered music reflected the time period when you were
growing up but were too young to call the music your own like the music that
ran around in the background of your growing up house on the mother housewife
radio or evening record player which in Ralph’s case was the music that got his
parents through his father’s soldierly slogging on unpronounceable Pacific
islands kicking ass and mother anxiously waiting at home for the other shoe to
fall or the dreaded military officer coming up to her door telling her the bad
news World War II. You know, Frank (Sinatra, the chairman of the board, that
all the bobbysoxer girls, the future mothers of Sam and Ralph’s generation
swooned over), The Andrew Sisters and their rums and coca colas, Peggy Lee
fronting for Benny Goodman and looking, looking hard for some Johnny to do
right, finally do right by her, etc. Other music, the music of their own
generation, classic rock and rock came more naturally since that is what they
wanted to hear when they had their transistor radios to their ear up in their
bedrooms.
That mention of transistor radios got
them yakking about that old instrument which got them through many a hard
teenage angst and alienation night. That yakking reflecting their both getting
mellow on the sweet beer and Ralph thinking that they had best switch to
Tennessee sipping whisky when the wait person came by again if they were to
make it through both sets that night. This transistor thing by the way for the
young was small enough to put in your pocket and put up to your ear like an
iPod or MP3 except you couldn’t download or anything like that. Primitive
technology okay but life-saving nevertheless. Just flip the dial although the
only station that mattered was WJDA, the local rock station (which had
previously strictly only played the music that got all of our parents through
their war before the rock break-out made somebody at the station realize that
you could made more advertising revenue selling ads for stuff like records,
drive-in movies, drive-in restaurants, and cool clothes and accessories than
refrigerators and stoves to adults).
Oh yeah, and the beauty of the transistor
you could take it up to your bedroom and shut out that aforementioned parents’
music without hassles. Nice, right. So yeah, they could hear Elvis sounding all
sexy according to one girl Sam knew even over the radio and who drove all the
girls crazy once they got a look at him on television, Chuck telling our
parents’ world that Mr. Beethoven and his crowd, Frank’s too, that they all had
to move over, Bo asking a very candid question about who put the rock in rock
and roll and offering himself up as a candidate, Buddy crooning against all
hope for his Peggy Sue (or was it Betty Lou), Jerry Lee inflaming all with his
raucous High School Confidential from the back of a flatbed truck,
etc. again.
The blues though, the rarified country
and electric urban blues of the likes of Son House, Robert Johnson, Muddy
Waters, James Cotton, and Howlin’ Wolf was an acquired taste. Acquired by Sam
through listening to folk music programs on that very same transistor radio in
the early 1960s after flipping the dial one Sunday night once he got tired of
what they claimed was rock music on WJDA and caught a Boston station. The main
focus was on other types of roots music but when the show would take a break
from down home mountain music, western swing ballads, and urban protest music
the DJ would play some cuts of country or electric blues. See all the big
folkies, Dylan, Tom Rush, Dave Van Ronk, people like that were wild to cover
the blues in the search for serious roots music from the American songbook. So
somebody, Sam didn’t know who, figured if everybody who was anybody was
covering the blues in that folk minute then it made sense to play the real
stuff. (Sam later carried Ralph along on the genre after they had met
down in Washington, D.C. in 1971, had been arrested and held in detention at
RFK Stadium for trying to shut down the government if it did not shut the
Vietnam War, had become life-long friends and Ralph began to dig the blues when
he came to Cambridge to visit).
The real stuff having been around for a
while, having been produced by the likes of Muddy and Howlin’ Wolf going back
to the 1940s big time black migration to the industrial plants of the Midwest
during World War II when there were plenty of jobs just waiting. But also
having been pushed to the background, way to the background with the rise of
rock and roll (although parts of rock make no sense, don’t work at all without
kudos to blues chords, check it out). So it took that combination of folk
minute and that well-hidden from view electric blues some time to filter
through Sam’s brain.
What
did not take a long time to do once Sam got “religion” was going crazy over
Howlin’ Wolf when he saw him perform. Once Sam had seen him practically eat
that harmonica when he was playing that instrument on How Many More Years.
There the Wolf was all sweating, running to high form and serious
professionalism (just ask the Stones about that polished professionalism when
he showed them how to really play Little Red Rooster which they had
covered early on in their career as they had covered many other Chess Records
blues numbers, as had in an ironic twist a whole generation English rockers in
the 1960s) and moving that big body to and fro to beat the band and playing
like god’s own avenging angel, if those angels played the harmonica, and if
they could play as well as he did. They both hoped that greying James
Montgomery, master harmonica player in his own right, blew the roof off of the
house as they spied the wait person coming their way and James moving onto the
stage getting ready to burn up the microphone. Yes, that blues calling is an
acquired taste and a lasting one.
When Women And Men Sang The Blues For Keeps-The Hook Is In Play- With John
Lee Hooker In Mind
By Lance Lawrence
“Hey guys, do you want to go to the PX
and have a couple of beers, near beers I guess you would call them but having a
few drinks beats sitting here in this dumbass barracks waiting for some trusty
corporal to look for volunteers to clean the latrine or make up beds or the ten
thousand other stupid things they make you do here in fucking Basic,” chortled
Ralph Morris as he asked Billy Raymond from Toledo and Bart Simmons from
Scranton that most important question. Ralph from Troy in upstate New York was
having a very hard time adjusting to the Army way, the military way the drill
sergeants called it, usually called it at about four in the morning when they
pulled a sneak inspection or had you carry your footlocker, Christ your
footlocker, out into the company formation for no rational reason. Had a hard
time adjusting there at Fort Gordon in godforsaken red clay Georgia, that red
clay no joke as he had almost eaten some one afternoon when the company was
doing bayonet practice drills out in the boonies and Drill Sergeant Mackey
suddenly called out for the company to hit the ground and he crashed into the
soft mucky soil. So every time the company was through for the day after supper
(supper at five o’clock, Jesus, that was almost lunch time back home) he would
head, alone or with his new found friends Basic friends this night Billy and
Bart who were also having their own adjustment problems, Billy had been
threatened with an Article 15 already, to the PX to drink the 3.2 authorized
standard Army beer that wouldn’t get anybody’s mother drunk and listen to the
jukebox to some tunes to make him forget.
Forget that he had actually joined the
Army unlike the hippies and college guys who were burning their draft cards
left and right up North. He hadn’t volunteered, signed up, no way, not at
first, but when his number was called he went just like his father, grandfather
and younger brother, Kenny, who actually had volunteered from the get-go back
in 1965 when the whole shooting match in Vietnam was just heating up and was
now safely home and trying to adjust as he said to the “real” world. That duty
to country when called was the way the Morris family viewed the world, viewed
it through patriotic eyes like most of the families in Troy who had sent their
sons off to wars, and Vietnam whatever was happening in Harvard Square, New
York City, Ann Arbor, New Haven, Old Town in Chicago or out on the whole
freaking West Coast was no exception, not even as he thought about heading to
the PX in 1969. Then he had made the stupid mistake of listening to Kenny who
told him that Vietnam was a very dangerous place for draftees since all a
draftee was good for was to be a “grunt,” an 11 Bravo, an infantryman, which is
all the Army wanted in late 1968 to fill in the depleted ranks after a hard
year of fighting when he was drafted (cannon-fodder Ralph would call it later
but that was much later after he had taken the fall) and so he had signed up
for a three year commitment, became Regular Army, an RA in front of his numbers
and had decided on to sign up for communications school as his job.
But that was before he took the oath,
before he was hustled out of the Army Recruiting Station in Albany and sent to
Fort Dix first for Basic Training which turned out to be full when he arrived
and so he had wound up at Fort Gordon just outside Augusta for Basic and this
awful feeling that he had made a terrible mistake, that while he had no serious
objection to going to Vietnam this mickey mouse crap was not for him. He had
found kindred in Billy and Bart and a couple of other guys from Newton up in
Massachusetts who would go to the section of the PX that was closed off from
the main body where you bought clothes, smokes, and toiletries and sit at the
small tables and drink a few beers, pop quarters in the jukebox and forget
about what a hellish day it had been until the place closed at 10 PM. Jesus, 10
PM back home he and his corner boys would just be going out the door going over
to Ready Teddy’s Bar to listen to live music, live blues music by Buddy and the
Nighthawks who covered Muddy, Howlin’ Wolf, Magic Slim, and even John Lee
Hooker on occasion.
That last performer, the Hook, was why
Ralph wanted to go to the PX, wanted company too. See Ralph thought the Hook
was dead, he had not heard otherwise, had notheard any recent stuff on The Blues Is The Dues radio show he
listened to on WSKI out of Saratoga Springs, out of Skidmore College about
twenty-five miles up the road from Troy where they played the Hook and the
others. Ralph had gotten all heated up when a week before he heard a group
called Canned Heat on the juke playing a song called On The Road Again with a beat that sounded very much like the boom
boom boom guitar stuff that the Hook had perfected along with that deep bass
voice that would put the fear into anybody who crossed that brother if he had
his whiskey and cocaine habits on. So he had made a call home to Ronny Black
who would know and sure enough who was doing the boom guitar work on the song
but one John Lee Hooker. The Army stuff was still chicken shit, probably always
would be but at least for a couple of hours he could cool his fragile head
listening to the real deal when they call off the names in the blues
pantheon.
Searching 10,000 Years
For A Hopi Warrior Dream-Once Again With The Late Native American Artist And
Poet T.C
Cannon In Mind
By Ronan Saint John
Gerald Scott was beset
by ancient dreams of late, maybe not going back 10,000 warrior years like he
liked to pretend, but maybe twenty years back (still you will know that he had
ancient dreams, 10,000 year dreams when you bring a word like beset, his word,
into the equation this early on). For back then, back in his youth he had dreamed
the dream of 10,000 year warriors, along with his friends, Jack Lennon and
James Lawson (not Jim or Jimmy not since childhood and mother’s call) when he
first went west, went via some covered wagon dream as he and they, along with
Sarah Mays (now Sarah Scott although she will when mad at Gerald revert to Mays
but that is another story which she can tell at her leisure) landed in Joshua
Tree out in the California high desert. The pack of them had just graduated
from their respective colleges and as youth might do back then, now too, they
decided to travel before settling down to whatever they would settle down to although
college debt-bound these days probably not likely and rather work, work as a
damn Starbuck’s barista if necessary to get the damn thing down before Social
Security benefits come into play.
I won’t name the colleges,
all four, since that too does not matter to our story and they can tell one and
all about their four years at their leisure as well except that Gerald had
taken a course in Native American history at his school. Had done so to fulfill
an elective requirement at first but got so into what the real history of those
many tribes were compared to the baloney he had been force-fed when he was a
kid in school, on television and in the cinema when those benighted indigenous
peoples were called Indians buying into the standard lie that these were the
lost tribes of the Northwest Passage and Christopher Columbus’ misdirected
signals to lay claim to the Americas (a name also reeking of illegitimacy but I
will stop on this road for guys like Seth Garth and Frank Jackman of American Left History blog can run the
rack on those injustices far better than I can). And so the trip with a few
dollars, a few knapsacks, a few sleeping bags and a beat up but serviceable
Toyota Camry purchased on the cheap from Sarah’s brother who was heading into
the Army.
I could probably spend a
good portion of what I have to say running circles around how this quartet
finally got to the high desert out in Joshua Tree but guys like Jack Kerouac,
who influenced my father in his time to head out to California in the 1960s
when he was young himself, Benny Gold, Lester Lawrence and a million other
literary travelers have beaten the paths out to the west already. Like I say
this is about a 10,000 year vision not some ill-begotten travelogue with AAA
ratings. I do have to mention the last leg, the last leg before sunny and hot
California desert because the route they travelled was through the states that
are square, as the writer Thomas Wolfe put when he was noting something very
different about the folk out there, the usurpers, those who stand on somebody
else’s land and memory. They had done a circuitous route around the four states
where Native Americans still had some existence, Utah, New Mexico, Nevada,
Arizona. At Gerald’s urging they stopped along the way at every reservation
area they came across, especially the Hopi reservation which joins those four
states together.
Gerald had told the
other three that he had had a strange dream one night when they were outside
Grand Island, Nebraska about a dance in which they, the three men, were
participating in someplace in the West in some canyon where the night fire was
flicking off the canyon walls and that flickering was driving the men to more
fervent dancing. Beyond that Gerald did not, could not, find meaning in what
that dream portended. Except he thought it had meant something about his
growing affinity for those long-lost warrior kings who were crucified by the trail
of tears the white man, he and his people, had brought upon some other people’s
land. And so the search for what that all meant. Since nobody was in a hurry to
get home or get to ocean California which meant at some point turning back East
and whatever they were going to do lives, everybody consented to the
route.
That route would indeed
portend something because along the way they wound up in Gallup, New Mexico
during August and were just in time for the annual Intertribal gatherings at
Red River Junction. They camped just outside the state park there on Friday and
the next day spend the day learning about Native American tribal lore from the
various tribes gathered at the site. One of the things that caught Gerald’s
attention, as it did the others including Sarah, was the mesmerizing effect of
the tribal dancing. Dancing that when it counted back in the day prepared the
warriors to confront whatever enemy of the day was to be fought-other tribes or
the encroaching white man with his womenfolk and youngsters. The rhythm, the
warrior beat filled their heads, although this was not spoken of until later,
until after they reached Joshua Tree, with their own warrior dreams, maybe pipe
dreams is a better way to put the situation.
Back at the campsite
that night as the sun was setting and the heat of the dusty day was settling
down when they came to their site they, Gerald first from the way I heard the
story, noticed a medium-sized camper with many logos, or what looked like logos
on it, a fire going and a few what looked like older men sitting around a big
drum with sticks playing to a methodical beat and chanting something that he could
not understand (and never did, then or later). They decided to get closer which
none of the men around the drum objected to. When the men took a break one of
the younger men waved the four devotees over and asked how they liked it, asked
if they had gone to the Intertribal. Yes, on both counts. He introduced himself
as Jack Two Feathers and asked their names, where they were from, and why they
were there. Gerald explained the Native American interest part.
Then Jack Two Feathers
mentioned that it was the tradition of his tribe, the Hopi, to enhance their
drumming, enhance their connection with their ancestors, and, laughingly, just
to get high to use peyote buttons. The Hopis had had trouble with the Bureau of
Indian Affairs and other law enforcement agencies over the use of the substance
which they, the Hopis, claimed was part of their religious experience and thus
protected under the white man’s United States Constitution. They would lose
that argument in the United States Supreme Court but among the young, and some
of the older fearless men they still carried out the peyote tradition.
Jack Two Feathers asked
them if they had ever tried peyote and Gerald mentioned that his father had
told him that he had as a proper 1960s young hippie type, but he had not. None
of the others had either. They all agreed, once Jack Two Feathers calmed them
down about the effects of the substance, to try some once he told them that it
would increase their spiritual well-being to see what it was all about. Jack
Two Feathers passed out some stuff that looked like mushrooms or something and
told them to chew the stuff well. After about an hour, and after Jack Two
Feathers had rejoined the older men around the drum who were ready to continue
their drumming ceremony, the buttons began to kick in.
Nothing particularly
dramatic happened that night except they were mesmerized by the beat of the
drum, mesmerized by some younger Hopis who started to dance to the beat of the
drums and would go into a fever pitch, and they did not come down from their
highs to finally go to sleep until almost dawn. Packing up the next afternoon
to head toward Joshua Tree via the Arizona desert and the Grand Canyon Jack Two
Feathers came by their laden car and passed a small packet of peyote buttons to
Gerald saying that maybe some time they too would see the face of sorrow, the
faces of warrior-kings who had roamed at will in these their lands before the
white man’s greed took it all away and left nothing good behind. Maybe even
have a spiritual journey out of the experiences as well.
Fast forward to Joshua
Tree a couple of weeks later and a couple of late night until dawn peyote
button rounds flames flickering against the grey, beige, red clay canyon walls,
the three men bare-chested while some others met drummed and Gerald and the others
finally found out what Jack Two-Feathers meant, felt that 10,000 year ancient warrior
dream and would be forever changed by the experience. Gerald laughed as they
started heading home about whether he should tell his father what happened.
Nah, he would never believe the tale.
When Marvel Comics Said Something About The Condition Of The World Today-About The Desperate Search For Some Rough Justice In This Wicked Old World-Marvel Studio’s “Black Panther” (2018)-A Film Review
Link to a NPR Christopher Lydon Open Source show on the on the social significance of the massive blockbuster Marvel Comics Studio creation Black Panther:
http://radioopensource.org/the-world-of-wakanda/
DVD Review
By Leslie Dumont
Black Panther, starring Chadwick Boseman, Michael B. Jordan and a host of black actors who have made their respective marks in Hollywood, directed by Ryan Coogler, 2018
Hey, I wasn’t trying to rain on anybody’s parade when I mentioned at a staff meeting that I did not think that the latest creation out of Marvel Comics Studio the financial blockbuster Black Panther was that interesting a story line given the hype created around the production and the astronomical box office numbers. I wasn’t even attempting to deal with the significance the film might have as the work of an almost totally black cast, black director and set in the virginal non-colonial land of Wakanda which had the added bonus of producing AND keeping its own vital raw resources, or resource is probably a better way to put it. All I knew was that for an over two hour film, seemingly all these Marvel productions need to be over two hours or are not worth the effort despite the hard fact, which is true here as well, that except for the advanced cinematic action technology on display they all could have used a bit more cutting in the editorial offices.
Maybe it is because I was never, ever a devotee of comic books or of films based on them, not even Superman if you can believe that, that I was somewhat cavalier with my comments. Nevertheless, for my blasphemy I was made to walk the plank. Bart Webber who revels in all things comic book and who has over the years done a stellar job of reviewing these Marvel cinematic productions was originally assigned by site manager Greg Green to do this review. But between my frankly merely off-hand comments and Greg’s having listened to a Christopher Lydon NPR Open Source hour on The World Of Wakanda where the old man had every academic he could squeeze in give their views of the world-historic significance of the first serious black comic superhero my number came up.
Since I have already alluded to the story-line weakness, which I do not think overcomes whatever black self-identity and self-worth it may impart on the audiences that watched the film, I will just run with that and let you check out the over-arching social and academic views by checking out the Open Source link above. Meaning I will take my own counsel on letting those factors get decided by time and history about who was right or wrong on the world-historic nature of a certain comic book character. You already know this is about a mystical African land named Wakanda which European imperialism was not able to exploit over the centuries it was in the killing fields of Africa trying to satiate its overweening greed. No mean task to have done, no question, but which by keeping quiet and keeping it valuable resource hidden from global view was able to prosper.
The minute you say that though you know the dramatic tension is going to be between those who want to get at the “gold” and those who want to keep the damn thing for their own internal use. That drama gets played out big time after the current Wakanda head of state got blown away and caused what amounted to a succession crisis between the legitimate son who wanted to keep to the old ways and the adopted son who wanted to use the Wakanda resources to bring down the neo-imperialism which was retarding post-colonial societal development. And by the way enrich and empower his own ambitions.
Naturally, real or fiction such tensions get a serious workout with first the legitimate son T’Challa (aka Black Panther) gaining the throne through the traditional rites of passage and then the pretender, the “bad guy” N’Jakada, (aka Killmonger) stepping up and asserting his rights also through combat and a preliminary victory. Sounds familiar even if two black guys are running the game this time. Just as naturally after a little time under N’ Jakada and his Pan-African dreams the Wakandans back T’Challa after the requisite number of mock battles and mortal combat between the pair. If I seem to have condensed the storyline too much well I have just done so to show that this is really something that guys could go crazy about, black or white. World-historic it is not and Greg Green and Christopher Lydon’s gushings are not going to change my mind on this one. The only virtue here is if Greg publishes this review he will think twice about not letting Bart Webber go through his paces and drag the story line out like he was being paid by the word.