Workers Vanguard No. 1017
|
8 February 2013
|
Down With the Capitalist EU! For a Workers Europe!
Greek Workers Battle Austerity, State Repression
FEBRUARY 5—In the early morning hours of January 25, Greek riot
police stormed the main train depot of the Athens metro system, breaking up an
occupation by striking workers who had courageously defied the government and
courts by keeping the metro shut down for nine days. Strikers were served with
orders to return to work or face imprisonment and firing under a government
“civil mobilization” order issued the day before. “Civil mobilization” was
invoked again today to break a seamen’s strike, which has for six days paralyzed
ferry service between the mainland and Greece’s many islands. A form of martial
law for so-called peacetime emergencies, it is an open declaration of war on the
working class. Its name harks back to the civil mobilization decrees for forced
labor that the Nazi occupiers issued during World War II, which were turned into
a dead letter in Greece by mass protests and general strikes in 1943.
As soon as the widely-despised coalition government of the
right-wing New Democracy (ND), the bourgeois Pan-Hellenic Socialist Movement
(PASOK) and the Democratic Left announced the “civil mobilization” order against
the metro workers last week, bus and trolley workers began a four-day-long
solidarity strike, holding out in defiance of court orders deeming their strike
illegal. The public power workers also organized a 24-hour strike in solidarity
with the metro workers on January 31. The government is now planning to ban such
solidarity strikes.
In breaking the metro workers strike and now taking aim at the
seamen, the Greek government has made it perfectly clear that it intends to
crush all resistance to the increasingly savage rounds of austerity measures.
The government crackdown on the unions comes on the heels of the arrest of 100
anarchist activists in Athens in December and January, and a bourgeois
propaganda campaign to smear the entire left as “terrorists.” Bonapartist
pronouncements are the order of the day, with the Minister of Public Order Nikos
Dendias ominously stating that “the country must finally settle its accounts
with the post-1974 era.” This is a reference to the period following the fall of
the bloody military junta that ruled from 1967-74, that is, the beginning of the
current period of bourgeois democracy in Greece.
The wave of strikes sweeping Greece has been sparked by the
implementation of a further $17.25 billion in killer cuts to wages, benefits and
social services. This is the price that the imperialist masters of the European
Union (EU) and International Monetary Fund (IMF) demanded the Greek working
people pay in exchange for billions more in bailout money for the bloodsucking
banks of the EU and the Greek bourgeoisie. With massive unemployment and poverty
ravaging the country, the metro workers and other public sector workers now face
pay cuts of up to 25 percent, having already lost on average nearly half their
income through successive rounds of cuts since the start of the economic crisis.
Even as wages are repeatedly slashed, inflation keeps rising, and the government
levies more and more taxes on the necessities of life, like heating oil. Athens
and Thessaloniki have been blanketed with toxic smog this winter because people
have been forced to burn wood to stay warm.
The fascist menace of Golden Dawn continues to grow—its
sympathizers claimed yet another victim with the racist murder of 27-year-old
Pakistani immigrant worker Shehzad Luqman on January 17 in Athens. The police,
many of them supporters of Golden Dawn, also terrorize immigrants and
foreigners. On February 1, the Athens police chased a Senegalese immigrant onto
metro tracks where he was electrocuted. They later tear-gassed people protesting
this crime. Since Greece completed its border fence with Turkey in December,
more than 20 desperate immigrants have drowned in the Aegean Sea trying to reach
Greek islands off the Turkish coast as an entry point to the EU.
As the worldwide capitalist financial crisis continues and the
economic and military ravages of imperialism drive millions more to leave their
home countries in search of an escape from abject poverty, it is crucial for the
workers movement to take up the fight for full citizenship rights for all
immigrants. Furthermore, it is a basic measure of self-defense of the unions and
the working class in Greece, with its heavy immigrant component, to mobilize in
mass united-front actions to crush the fascist scum of Golden Dawn. As our
comrades of the Trotskyist Group of Greece explained in their November 2012
leaflet “Capitalists Bleed Greek Working Class” (reprinted in WV No.
1013, 23 November 2012):
“What is necessary is to fight to remove the political obstacles
to mobilizing the power of the trade unions against Golden Dawn. The KKE
[Communist Party of Greece] has the social weight in the trade unions to take
the lead in doing this, but its promotion of illusions in bourgeois democracy
and its nationalist populism are barriers. The reformist organizations that
compose groups such as Antarsya also reinforce the political obstacles, in
particular by tailing the pro-EU Syriza coalition, which promises to provide
immigrants more ‘humane’ conditions of imprisonment and to put more cops on the
streets to fight ‘crime’.”
A January 19 demonstration in Athens was organized by KEERFA, an
“anti-fascist front” led by the Socialist Workers Party (SEK), which is
affiliated with the British SWP and part of the Antarsya coalition. However, the
SEK’s pretensions to be fighters against fascism were exposed by a grotesque
article called “Patriotism and Internationalism” (Workers Solidarity, 9
January), which argues that nationalism and internationalism are “synonymous and
interdependent.” The SEK perpetuates the lie that there is a common national
interest between the exploiters and the exploited: “The national (identity)
connects him [the worker] with all his fellow countrymen with whom he fights to
resolve the different national issues.”
Genuine Marxists are staunch opponents of nationalism, a bourgeois
ideology that serves to tie workers to the class enemy. In Greece, nationalism
means the oppression of national minorities such as the Macedonians, Vlachs,
Pomaks, Turks and Albanians. Our comrades of the TGG fight for full democratic
rights for the national minorities, for the right of self-determination for the
Macedonian minority in Greece and for a socialist federation of the Balkans as
the only way to resolve the myriad national questions in the region.
It is telling that as the forces of the capitalist state were
rounding up anarchist activists and smashing the metro strike, Syriza (Coalition
of the Radical Left) leader Alexis Tsipras was on an international tour to meet
with representatives of the imperialist rulers in Germany and the U.S. Tsipras,
who rose to prominence after Syriza came in second in the last elections, was
clearly seeking to reassure the imperialists that Syriza represents absolutely
no threat to their interests in Greece. In a speech to the Brookings
Institution, a U.S. bourgeois think tank, Tsipras said: “Those who engage in
scare-mongering will tell you that our party will come to power, rip up our
agreements with the European Union and the IMF, take our country out of the euro
zone. My party, Syriza, doesn’t want any of these things” (Dow Jones Business
News, 25 January).
In contrast to the fake Trotskyist organizations inside Syriza and
in the Antarsya coalition who all salivated at the prospect of a “left
government” around the last elections, the TGG has always told the truth about
Syriza—that it accepts the capitalist order and the EU, seeking only to (barely)
ameliorate the terms of extortion. There is no way forward for the workers and
poor of Greece and indeed, the workers of all of Europe, without a sharp
struggle against the imperialist EU, the central mechanism by which the combined
capitalist powers have imposed austerity on their own working classes, slashed
wages and rolled back trade-union rights and work conditions.
While the KKE tops have made a point of opposing the EU and of
rejecting the call to join a capitalist government of the left with Syriza,
their consistent refusal to defend anarchists against capitalist state
repression is a clear example of their fundamental loyalty to bourgeois
democracy. Far from standing up to the recent propaganda campaign by the
government and bourgeois press branding everyone on the left, and even Syriza,
as defenders of “terrorism,” the KKE has echoed the bourgeois denunciations of
violence. It has also condemned anarchists for occupying offices of the
Democratic Left—one of the ruling parties.
The 100 anarchist activists arrested in raids in December and
January were themselves violently evicted and arrested by the cops for the
“crime” of occupying abandoned buildings in downtown Athens. The KKE’s refusal
to defend anarchists paves the way for attacks against its own supporters. The
KKE’s trade-union activists from the PAME formation were victims of a vicious
police attack on January 30 when riot cops used tear gas and batons to break up
a protest at the office of the Minister of Labor by PAME members, resulting in
35 arrests. The TGG demands: Drop all charges against the anarchist
activists and the PAME protesters!
The government may have succeeded in forcing the metro workers back
to work, but as the seamen’s and other recent strikes by transport workers,
shipyard workers, doctors and nurses have shown, the government has not
succeeded in extinguishing class struggle. This wave of strikes and protests
demonstrates the deep anger and militancy of the Greek working class, which has
the power to fight in the interests of all those thrown on the scrap heap by the
capitalist crisis. The government response to the metro and seamen’s strikes
underscores just how fearful the bourgeoisie is of such strikes spreading.
In a January 29 statement, the New Left Current (NAR), which
emerged from a 1989 split in the KKE and is the biggest force inside Antarsya,
correctly noted that the reformist labor bureaucracy of the GSEE and ADEDY union
federations failed to organize united struggle by all the unions to defend the
striking metro workers. NAR calls for coordinated action by the whole of the
working people in a front “for anti-capitalist overthrow” of the policies of the
government. Yet its statement says nothing about who or what is to replace the
existing government. And when it says that Syriza will be judged on its response
to the current struggles, it is obviously leaving the door open for a left
capitalist government led by Syriza.
Uniting the power of the trade unions in coordinated action against
the capitalist assault—instead of dissipating that power by having rolling
strikes at different times in different sectors—is certainly called for. But
bringing to bear the full power of the working class would represent a challenge
to the whole capitalist order in Greece, and hence is unacceptable to the
pro-capitalist GSEE and ADEDY union tops. The working class urgently needs a
revolutionary leadership that links the daily struggles against capitalist
austerity to the need to overthrow the capitalist order.
Such a leadership would mobilize around transitional demands such
as a shorter workweek with no loss of pay and a massive program of public works
to provide jobs, the indexing of wages to inflation, and that the capitalists
open their (real) books to expose their exploitation and robbery of the workers.
Such demands point to the need for the proletariat to organize more broadly to
fight for the expropriation of the capitalist means of production and the
establishment of a planned economy under workers rule, where production would be
based on social need, not profit. In other words, the working class must fight
for the overthrow of the capitalist state, not to take control of the existing
state in the form of a left capitalist government. Such revolutionary struggle
would necessarily need to extend from tiny, dependent Greece to other countries
of the region and in particular to the imperialist centers where workers are
also being starved. This is the perspective that our comrades of the TGG fight
for.
The following article, translated from German and adapted for
Workers Vanguard, is taken from Spartakist No. 196 (January 2013),
newspaper of the Spartakist-Arbeiterpartei Deutschlands, German section of the
International Communist League. It is based on a forum by our comrade Sylvia
that was held in September 2012.
* * *
I visited Greece a few times between November 2011 and July 2012.
Although the austerity programs had been in force for quite a while, the effects
were not all that evident that November. In contrast, many changes had occurred
by May and even more by July-August. I’m not talking about the buildings in
central Athens that burned to the ground in the course of protest demos and
weren’t rebuilt but rather about seeing real despair on people’s faces, with
their increasing poverty evident in their clothing.
I lived in Greece for a couple of years. Homelessness, previously
rare, has grown tremendously since then. Youth unemployment now stands at around
50 percent and, while this has been a fact of life in Spain for years, it hadn’t
been that way in Greek society. Whenever I’m in Athens, I always revisit the
districts where I’ve lived to take a look at the shops and the people. In
November 2011, about a quarter of the stores had shut their doors—a bakery or a
pet store—but in July-August it was at least a third, on many blocks even half
the stores.
The drastic change became more evident when talking with friends or
people on the street. This was apparent with health care. There were big
protests at every public building, particularly hospitals, and just this week a
group of furious pensioners stormed the Ministry of Health because they have to
pay for their medicine now. The state isn’t paying and many who were just barely
getting by have slid into total poverty. On top of all the job cuts there have
been massive pay cuts for those still working—in many fields as much as 25
percent. Pensions have also been slashed.
All this is taking place at the behest of the Troika, a group
consisting of the EU, IMF and the European Central Bank (ECB). The Troika’s aim
is to make sure the Greek working class pays the German and French banks and
insurance companies. When then-prime minister George Papandreou suggested
holding a referendum on the Troika’s austerity dictates in November 2011, he was
gone in a matter of days, replaced by a technocrat named Lucas Papademos who,
interestingly enough, had once been vice president of the ECB.
Since then there have been two elections. It’s obvious that
traditional voting patterns have changed. Whereas in the past either PASOK or
the conservative New Democracy ruled, since the June elections a coalition of
the ND, PASOK and the Democratic Left has been ruling the country. But Syriza—to
which former Eurocommunists, Maoists and a number of fake Trotskyist groups
belong—emerged as the second most powerful force in both elections. Previously
Syriza had been, in terms of votes, a relatively insignificant group, but in May
it obtained 16 percent and in June over 26 percent.
Politically, the situation in Greece is extremely polarized. While
participation in the elections has steadily fallen over the years—in 2004 it was
76 percent, now it is 62 percent—political discussions take place everywhere in
the streets, whether you’re going out for a coffee or buying cigarettes. People
are very politicized, very furious and most of those who voted for Syriza in
2012 did so because they regarded it as a lesser evil.
For Workers United-Front Action to Stop the Fascists!
The deepening crisis is fueling the flames of nationalism,
chauvinism and racism. People are looking for scapegoats, and hunting down
immigrants has reached incredible proportions since the June elections. The
fascists of Chrysi Avgi (Golden Dawn) got around 7 percent of the vote in both
elections. They have a lot of support in the army and the police. The Greek
paper To Vima (11 May 2012) found out that approximately half the police
force voted for Golden Dawn in the May elections. Golden Dawn is of the same ilk
as the notorious Nazi-loving Security Battalions and the “X” group of General
Georgios Grivas—counterrevolutionary terror bands that murdered Communists in
the Second World War and the ensuing Greek Civil War.
The fascists are the shock troops of national chauvinist reaction.
They are kept in reserve by the bourgeoisie because they serve as a useful
weapon against the workers in times of crisis. Today in Greece, we can see very
clearly that fascism is a product of collapsing capitalism, fed by joblessness
and the pauperization of the petty bourgeoisie. So, for us Marxists it’s obvious
that fascism can be eradicated only when the system of wage slavery is
eliminated. And the decisive force for this is the working class because, with
its hands on the levers of production, it generates profit for the bourgeoisie.
Elevating the working class to consciousness of its historic task—overthrowing
capitalism—requires a revolutionary party.
It was with horror that I learned from our comrades of the
Trotskyist Group of Greece about the explosion of terror against immigrants,
“illegals,” non-Greeks. Fascist terror against immigrants goes hand in hand with
state repression. The state has set up camps and is carrying out mass arrests in
an operation cynically titled “Xenios Zeus” (Zeus as protector of guests and
hospitality). In early August, 2,000 immigrants were arrested in Athens and
similar actions were carried out in major cities like Patras and Thessaloniki.
By the end of August, over 12,000 immigrants had been arrested or imprisoned.
The Greek police’s “Special Units for the Restoration of Public Order” went into
the cities and arrested people, working hand in glove with the largely fascist
citizen militias that exist in some towns.
In August, there was a TV report about a guy who shot two Albanian
people. Normally, someone suspected of manslaughter or murder is put into
investigative detention. Not here. At the same time, there are commercials on TV
showing supposedly happy “illegals” with shopping bags in detention camps, who
are then deported. In July, a Golden Dawn fascist physically assaulted a
representative of Syriza and a KKE member of parliament on a TV panel
discussion. This, of course, provoked widespread furor. Syriza protested
immediately and organized some demos. We went to one that was organized by the
SEK, the Greek fraternal organization of Marx 21 in Germany, i.e., the
Cliffites. The demo was relatively small, attended almost solely by their own
members. They demanded a state investigation into the ties between the fascists
and the police. That is, they promote the illusion that the capitalist state can
do away with the fascists.
But what is urgently necessary are defense actions to smash the
fascists. These must be carried out with the broadest participation of the
working class, joining together with the victims of the assaults. In areas with
a high percentage of immigrants, workers defense groups must put an end to the
attacks. Itself a prime target of fascist terror, the KKE possesses, through its
trade-union formation PAME, the roots and authority in the working class to stop
the Nazis by linking up with all those organized in the unions in united-front
actions. But its reformist program of class collaboration prevents the KKE from
doing this. The KKE’s reaction to the fascist assault on its own MP was to call
upon those who had voted for the Nazis to instead vote for the KKE. This is
incredible, but it truly encapsulates the KKE’s nationalism, populism and
electoral cretinism. What is required is a revolutionary Leninist-Trotskyist
party based on the working class. This party must be a tribune of all the
oppressed as opposed to wooing votes on the basis of nationalism.
For a Socialist Federation of the Balkans!
The Greek working class is relatively small but militant. This
underlines the need for it to seek allies outside the country, for instance, its
class brothers elsewhere in the Balkans as well as in Turkey and Germany. But
when you preach nationalism like the KKE, then you’re undermining this
international solidarity. This is one of the reasons we regard nationalism as
the main ideological obstacle to the struggle for socialism in Greece. One
example: the region in the north of the country around Thessaloniki is called
Macedonia in Greek. Following the destruction of the Yugoslav deformed workers
state at the beginning of the 1990s, the former Yugoslav republic of Macedonia
sought to include “Macedonia” in its name, triggering a gigantic wave of
chauvinism in Greece. The KKE wrote at the time: “We don’t let any foreign
nationalist lay claim to even a centimeter of Greek soil” (KKE pamphlet
“Positions on the Balkans,” February 1992).
We of the ICL are unambiguously for Macedonia’s right to
self-determination, including the right of Macedonians in Greece to secede and
join Macedonia. The Greek bourgeoisie fears that this part of “their” country
called Macedonia could be taken away from them if Macedonians were granted the
right to self-determination. In discussions you see just how touchy the
Macedonia question is, no matter what the political coloration of your
discussion partners might be. Either they become enraged, or they won’t talk
about it with you. It is very difficult to find someone who considers socialism
and opposition to national oppression more important than the boundaries of a
capitalist Greece, which were drawn up through a series of wars and expulsions.
This shows that nationalism is one of the core questions.
Down With the Imperialist EU!
Unfortunately, solidarity actions with the Greek populace are few
and far between in Germany. This can be attributed partly to the fact that the
Social Democratic Party (SPD) and the Left Party, as well as the trade unions
they lead, support the EU—a truly classic example of class collaboration. Thus,
former chancellor Helmut Schmidt of the SPD warned of a return to nationalism
should the EU come apart, while Sarah Wagenknecht of the Left Party stated that
the euro had to be defended. In this manner, any possible protests of the German
working class are to be channeled into support for the bourgeoisie. We of the
ICL oppose the EU on principle, fighting for its destruction through
international class struggle. Our starting point is what is in the interests of
the working class on this question. We are for the United Socialist States of
Europe. The EU is an instrument of the European capitalists for the exploitation
of the working classes of Europe, led mainly by the axis of the German and
French imperialist powers.
The euro is a monetary instrument of the EU. Through it, Greece has
no control over its currency. It cannot devalue its currency to improve its
competitiveness and keep debt under control. Perhaps Greece would be better off
without the euro, although a Greek currency wouldn’t protect the working class
from capitalist devastation either.
The EU arose in the fifties as an economic alliance of the
imperialists against the Soviet Union. The Soviet state, created in the October
Revolution of 1917 through the expropriation of the capitalist class and the
collectivization of the means of production, remained a workers state despite
its subsequent bureaucratic degeneration under Stalin. We Trotskyists offered
unconditional military defense against the imperialists and against internal
counterrevolution while fighting for proletarian political revolution to
overthrow the Stalinists. Our defense of the Soviet Union is one reason why we
were against the European Union from the outset.
The present crisis illuminates the age of imperialism. You can see
how countries are ever more tightly integrated into the world market, finance
capital is exported and industry is concentrated in monopolies. At the same
time, capitalism rests upon nation states that come into conflict with one
another in the worldwide pursuit of profits and new spheres of exploitation.
Thus, the nation state constitutes a fetter on the further development of the
productive forces. For the working class and the oppressed there is only one way
out—socialist revolution that expropriates the bourgeoisie and establishes an
international planned economy under workers rule. Every battle against the
austerity measures, whether in Greece or in Spain, is a Europe-wide and an
international struggle. Resistance to the EU is only the starting point. Since
the cause of the crisis lies in the system of world capitalism, the solution is
its overthrow.
The German bourgeoisie is unyielding in its demand that its
austerity diktats be realized. If this causes its foreign markets to collapse,
the German ruling class will have shot itself in the foot since its economy is
so highly export-oriented. Even within the central axis of the EU—France and
Germany—there are differences. While France is suffering from a trade deficit of
32 billion euros, Germany has amassed a 73 billion euro export surplus relative
to the other euro zone countries.
The SPD and trade unions have contributed to the austerity diktat
by promoting the protectionist scheme “Standort Deutschland.” Among its spawn is
“Agenda 2010” with its massive cuts in wages, expansion of contract labor and
the like. Other European capitalists can see how these increased the rate of
profit for the German bourgeoisie and consider them worth copying in their own
countries. Conversely, the assaults on the Greek working class provide a model
for attacks elsewhere.
Fake Trotskyists Tail Syriza
While supporting the capitalist EU, Syriza campaigned against the
Troika’s austerity memorandum and argued for renegotiating the conditions that
were set. Syriza chair Alexis Tsipras has promised economic and political
stability and is in favor of working with the Troika to provide Greek banks with
new capital. Many reformist groups in and outside Greece have signed up as water
boys for Syriza, e.g., the Grantites of Marxistiki Foni and the Cliffites of the
Democratic Workers Left (DEA), who are linked to the International Socialist
Organization in the U.S.
The DEA portrayed its support to Syriza as proletarian
internationalism and said, “We are confronting the fact that in a month’s time,
Syriza will be the leading party in the country. So we will be called on at that
point to form a government that can transform things for the people of Greece”
(Socialist Worker [U.S.], 23 May 2012). Then there is the Antarsya
coalition, in which the Cliffite SEK as well the OKDE-Spartakos of the Pabloite
United Secretariat (USec) participate. Antarsya ran its own candidates in the
elections. Their intent was to pressure Syriza and use it to strengthen the
“resistance.” Leading British SWPer Alex Callinicos said: “Antarsya has made it
clear that it sees itself working alongside and in dialogue with those who
support Syriza. The stronger its voice is, the greater the pressure will be on
Syriza” (Socialist Worker [Britain], 2 June 2012). Particularly charming
was that the USec, the “International” of OKDE-Spartakos, didn’t even support
the candidates of its own section in Greece but rather those of Syriza!
All these reformist groups are not about socialism but rather are
fighting for a “government of the left” with better policies, which is nothing
but a capitalist government. At their core, such politics are pro-EU and
pro-capitalist. Illusions in a left capitalist government are an obstacle to
leading the working class on the path to revolution, for which the political
independence of the working class is indispensable. Racism, poverty,
exploitation and imperialist dominance cannot be ended through reformist
pressure politics but only through the seizure of power by the working class.
And for this what is needed is an authentic Leninist-Trotskyist party.
Greek Trotskyists Said: Vote KKE! No Vote for Syriza!
We gave critical support to the KKE in the June elections. Our
starting point as Marxists is that the working class cannot achieve significant
victories through bourgeois elections, but we do utilize them as an opportunity
to attain a hearing among broader masses of workers. For this, we also employ
tactics like critical electoral support.
On the other hand, reformists, whether supporters of the DEA,
Antarsya or the anarchists, fundamentally share a bourgeois conception of
elections. While the reformists believe that a better system can be attained
through elections, the anarchists think that if people didn’t vote the system
would break down. I was there and assisted our comrades of the Greek section in
their critical support campaign. We had some discussion with people from
Antarsya, but it was amusing to talk with the anarchists in their center
“Notios.” They’d probably never voted before in their lives, but now they were
tying themselves in knots and admitted that they were going to vote for Antarsya
or Syriza—but really only as “lesser evils”!
We approach bourgeois elections from a revolutionary standpoint. Of
course, we’re willing to employ the talk shop of parliament as a platform, but
we make clear to the masses that the core of the state is special bodies of
armed men like the police, the army and prisons. This core is not subject to
election and is not reformable. Marx concluded that the state had to be smashed
and destroyed in the course of a revolution if the capitalist system was to be
overthrown. Reformism helps keep capitalism alive. Our campaign offering
critical support provided us with the opportunity to talk with members of the
KKE, and naturally with other leftists as well, about the KKE’s program and our
own.
Generally, it’s difficult to approach KKE members at major
demonstrations and forums. It’s a very well-organized reformist, Stalinist mass
party. A genuine phenomenon: being face-to-face with a Stalinist party with
hundreds of thousands of supporters twenty years after counterrevolution in the
USSR and East Europe, a party deeply rooted in society and the historic party of
the Greek working class. They have a daily paper, many members of parliament and
have the trust of the most politically advanced workers in Greece. Anyone who’s
been in Greece and seen a KKE demo—well, it’s very impressive how well organized
they are. And we were able to come into much more contact with them as a result
of our campaign. In any case, we’re almost the only leftists to approach the KKE
and talk with them since other leftists won’t debate the KKE out of
anti-Communism.
The basis for our critical support was the KKE’s refusal to join
with Syriza in building a coalition of the left. The British SWP and SEK
immediately termed the KKE’s position “sectarian”—a very popular term of
reproof. Additionally, the KKE was for canceling the Greek debt and had for some
time called for withdrawal from the EU and NATO. We put out a flyer “Vote KKE!
No Vote for Syriza!” (see WV No. 1005, 6 July 2012). Had the KKE won the
elections, it would have been a black eye for the EU and the Greek
bourgeoisie.
The Greek section’s campaign was supported by an international team
of comrades from the U.S., Britain, France and Germany. Critical electoral
support, of course, means that we’re also critical. Central to our criticism is
the KKE’s nationalism, expressed for example in their terming themselves
patriots and continually talking about the “people.” This is an anti-Marxist
concept because “the people” also includes the class enemy of the Greek workers,
the Greek bourgeoisie, while excluding their most important allies, such as the
Turkish or German proletariat.
In discussions with KKE members they say, “Of course, the Greek
bourgeoisie isn’t part of the people.” Nonetheless, it’s a concept that is
diametrically opposed to a class understanding. At the same time, the slogan
“Workers of the World, Unite!” always appears on the title page of the KKE paper
Rizospastis. This is, of course, a contradiction. The KKE argues for
making use of Greece’s resources in the interests of the Greek people, an
expression of the Stalinist program of building “socialism in one country.” The
concept of socialism in Greece alone, with an economy largely based on tourism
and ownership of an international merchant fleet, is a bit ridiculous. This is
even more so the case when you consider that it didn’t work out in one of the
most resource-rich countries on earth, namely the Soviet Union.
The Bolshevik Party under the leadership of Lenin and Trotsky was
internationalist through and through, and this enabled it to lead the
multinational working class of tsarist Russia to power in the October Revolution
of 1917. It was clear to the Bolsheviks that the revolution could not be
maintained over the long term, nor could socialism be constructed, as long as
the Soviet workers state remained isolated. Socialism is based on abundance for
all, which will be brought about through the all-sided development of the most
modern forces of production, socialist planning and an international division of
labor. For the Bolsheviks, the October Revolution was to be the first in a
series of revolutions around the world, and they founded the Third (Communist)
International as the instrument for the working class to conquer power in other
countries.
Due to the sustained isolation, poverty and backwardness of the
newly founded Soviet Union, a bureaucratic caste arose that usurped power in a
political counterrevolution in early 1924. The theory of building “socialism in
one country” promulgated by Stalin in late 1924 codified the conservatism of
this bureaucratic layer. This layer feared the proletariat, against whom it
defended its privileges, and sought to make peace with the imperialist powers.
Simultaneously, its privileges were derived from the collectivized economy of
the Soviet Union, where the capitalist class had been expropriated. At every
turn, the Left Opposition led by Trotsky battled the degeneration of the Soviet
Union and the Communist International. In the Trotskyist analysis, the Soviet
Union became a bureaucratically degenerated workers state. The imperialists
confronted the Soviet Union with unyielding hostility despite all its attempts
at appeasement.
For a Leninist-Trotskyist Party!
Virtually every fake Trotskyist current on the planet is
represented in Greece, and their rotten politics have given Trotskyism a bad
name—it is often seen as anti-Communist and social-democratic. When we were
doing election campaigning at 6 a.m. in Athens’ port of Piraeus, someone turned
and asked, “How come Trotskyists are supporting the Stalinists?” and he started
a debate. Our Greek group doesn’t share the petty-bourgeois, anti-Communist
prejudices of other leftists. And in order to make a revolution in Greece and
the rest of the Balkans, you must break the working class from its false
leadership and win it to a genuinely Leninist-Trotskyist party.
Other questions played a large role in the founding of our Greek
section in 2004. The woman question is a truly central one for Greece. One
example is the bride price, which was officially done away with only in 1986.
Greece is not a secular country, there are Orthodox priests running around
everywhere, all the time—I even observed a woman confessing on the street.
Another example: the schools are blessed every year. When the government is
sworn in, a priest is present. The questions of the church, capitalism and
women’s oppression go hand in hand. One can fight for the liberation of women
only if one fights to overthrow capitalism, and one cannot overthrow capitalism
if one doesn’t fight for women’s liberation.
The Balkans are a veritable mosaic of national minorities, and if
you lack a program to address the national question, then you really can’t be a
proletarian revolutionary. Hence, this was an important point in the founding of
our Greek section. You really need an internationalist perspective, otherwise
all there will be is national oppression and the spilling of blood, only a fight
for a Greater Bulgaria or a Greater Greece, which is counterposed to socialism
and all-sided liberation, i.e., to the interests of the multinational working
class of the Balkans.
The other important question is Cyprus. We struggle against the
all-pervasive anti-Turkish chauvinism in Greece. Turkey is, after all, the
historic enemy of the Greek bourgeoisie, but the Turkish proletariat is not the
enemy of the Greek working class. On the contrary, it is really its most
important ally. Thus, we call for the withdrawal of all troops from
Cyprus—Greek, Turkish, British and UN. In contrast, the Greek left, including
the KKE, tells you only how bad the Turkish troops are.
The KKE’s program contains a whole series of reformist demands
right down to nationalist positions in defense of Greece’s boundaries, but it
also contains a lot of rhetoric that suggests socialism sometime in the future.
However, the Greek CP lacks any program that would link up the necessary
struggle for people’s daily needs with the struggle for the conquest of power by
the working class. And this is really the main task of a revolutionary
Trotskyist party, preparing our class and leading it to power. Our role as a
small international propaganda group is to lay the basis for the construction of
such a party, a party that will be part of the reforged Fourth International,
which we fight for here in Germany as well.