At The Dawn Of The Modern Age-William Manchester’s “A World
Lit Only By Fire”-A Book Review
Book Review
By Leslie Dumont
A World Lit Only By Fire, William Manchester,
When I was in elementary school, fifth grade I think, we
studied the Middle Ages, what then was called the Dark Ages. I was thinking
about that phrase when I was called upon by Greg Green to review a book about
that time, the time when not much seemed to be happening in the world, the
Western European world anyway, and the time immediately after the break-through
times of the Renaissance in William Manchester’s general history of the period A World Lit Only By Fire. Thinking how historical
charactizations give way to later interpretations although after reading this
book I still believe what were called the Dark Ages, an age dominated by feudal
relations on the land and more importantly the champ-down of the Catholic
Church which truly was universal, Western European universal, a major landowner
in its own right, and which kept tight reins on this overall static society.
The biggest idea that I took away from this reading was how
very different those societies were organized and what must have animated the
minds of even the best of them. Writers like Dante whose Divine Comedy is a major literary masterpiece of the time must have
such a different set of assumptions about the world than ours that it is hard
to see how we can relate to the times and his thoughts except as benchmarks toward
the “progress” of history going forward. A world where the vast bulk of the
population lived “short, nasty brutish lives” as the old time philosopher Hobbes
would comment later, lived in the village or town and did not venture further.
A world where darkness was a time of fear and disquiet. A world at the top levels
of society, the levels we know about since they left written records in Latin
and in the vernacular against the fates of the unlettered and illiterate where
intrigue, sabotage, murder and mayhem were the order of the day just like today
but without the public relations flaks to filter out the real deal and the fluff.
The most interesting part of the book deals with that point
around 1400 give or take a few decades when things started to burst through the
logjam of the old world order. Of course the Renaissance which we know mainly
through the incredible artistic revival of the times, above all Leonardo, and
the literature too also included some very sharp political controversies between
the secular and religious authorities, essentially the beginning of the end of
the massive Catholic Church centered in Rome and led by a long succession of Popes,
Anti-Popes, Co-Popes and the like. Machiavelli a big name from the time had it
down pretty well about where things were headed and how princes could get there.
Although the bulk of the art was still drawing from the Old Testament tales of
and seemingly endless number of painting concerning the death of Jesus Christ a
small nudge toward more secular themes was growing which would flower when the
Dutch and Flemish ruled the trade routes.
Probably with the liberating efforts, the new thinking, the new
emphasis on the vernacular, the opening up of the world of ideas after the dead
end of Scholasticism took a tumble the Renaissance influence led to the big
controversy of the times between a corrupt Catholic Church and the zeal for
reform led by Martin Luther in the early 1500s. There had been scattered reformers
and reform movements before that time but they mainly had been finished off at
the stake. There was a new breeze blowing not against religion but against the
old religious practices, that breeze including plenty of wars to see who would
win the hearts of the peoples. A very important time and Manchester spent a good
deal of time highlighting Luther’s efforts.
Of course this is also a time when at least a small segment
of society was ready to break out of Europe, explore the world and this really
was breakthrough in the age of discovery. I am not sure I agree with Manchester’s
spending so much time on Magellan as the epitome of the spirit of the times but
no question this period of trade, commerce, new inventions and such is that edge
of the modern world whose ideas and trends have still not been fully played out
even today.
A good read with plenty of gossipy stuff about people like the
Borgias, the corrupt Popes and their progeny, and the place of the extraordinary
artists from these times. From Botticelli’s Venus
to all the good works Leonardo, Raphael and Michelangelo. (Although perhaps reflecting
the times he wrote the book in nothing about the possible homosexuality of guys
like Leonardo and Michelangelo so how things have changed in the last few decades
on that score.)